A Building Condition Assessment (BCA) is a systematic evaluation of a property’s physical inventory used to determine its current state and future capital requirements. For investors and property managers across Canada—from the high-density residential towers of Toronto to the industrial hubs of Edmonton—mastering how to describe the condition of a building is essential for mitigating financial risk and ensuring regulatory compliance.
Beyond simple maintenance, a BCA serves as a critical pillar of Environmental Due Diligence. While a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) identifies subsurface risks and contamination, the BCA evaluates the “above-ground” viability of the asset. Together, they provide a holistic view of a property’s liabilities.
The Professional Framework for Building Descriptors
To provide a reliable baseline, professionals use standardized descriptors aligned with ASTM E2018-15 standards. These categories allow an accredited assessor to translate physical observations into clear financial risk profiles. When determining how to describe the condition of a building, use the following hierarchy:
- Excellent: New or very well-maintained; no physical deficiencies noted.
- Good: Systems are functional and performing their intended purpose; only routine operating expenses (OpEx) are anticipated.
- Fair: Showing signs of wear or systemic aging; deferred maintenance is present, but the system remains functional.
- Poor: Significant material defects identified; the system requires immediate corrective action to prevent further deterioration.
- Unsatisfactory: The system has reached the end of its Expected Useful Life (EUL) and poses a potential life-safety risk.
Standard Terms for Quantifying Risk
To speak the language of a building scientist, you must move beyond generic adjectives. Professional reports utilize specific technical terminology to quantify risk and protect the Loan-to-Value (LTV) ratio for lenders:
- Deferred Maintenance: Necessary repairs that were postponed, often resulting in higher short-term costs.
- Remaining Useful Life (RUL): The estimated years a system (e.g., HVAC or roofing) will remain functional before replacement.
- Material Defect: A deficiency that significantly impacts the value, integrity, or safety of the property.
- Opinions of Costs: Professional estimates for remedial work, categorized by urgency. These are budgetary guides, not fixed construction bids.
Building Systems Checklist: Technical Scope
|
System |
What to Look For |
Professional Descriptors |
|
Foundation |
Cracks, settlement, or water ingress. |
Structurally Sound, Compromised. |
|
Roofing |
Standing water, membrane degradation. |
Weather-tight, End of Life (EOL). |
|
Electrical |
Capacity, wiring age, code compliance. |
Functional, Obsolete, Life-Safety Risk. |
|
Plumbing |
Leakage, pipe corrosion (e.g., Kitec). |
Operational, Materially Deficient. |
Opinions of Costs vs. Probable Costs
Modern assessments follow the ASTM E2018-15 standard, which mandates providing “Opinions of Costs” to ensure a neutral, data-driven view. These are categorized to assist in long-term capital planning:
- Immediate Costs (0–1 Year): Urgent expenditures for life-safety issues or building code violations.
- Short-Term Costs (1–3 Years): Anticipated capital requirements for systems nearing their EUL.
FAQ: Building Condition and Material Concerns
What are the levels of building condition?
Professionals generally categorize buildings as Good, Fair, Poor, or Unsatisfactory. This helps stakeholders prioritize capital projects based on the severity of the deficiency.
How do you write a building condition report?
In Canada, a professional BCA must be authored by qualified professionals—typically P.Eng or Architect designations. It includes a methodology statement, visual observations, RUL analysis, and a comprehensive table of Opinions of Costs.
Patrick Buffalo
Latest posts by Patrick Buffalo (see all)
- All-in-one Commercial Building Inspection Checklist - September 20, 2021
- How To Choose The Right Location For Your Business - July 28, 2021
- What to know while ordering a Property Condition Assessment? - March 22, 2021
